Figure 5-13: Red whole track of outbound container ownship

Figure 5-14: Vessel Track of container ship in red at scene

Figure 5-15: small ship’s echo mixed with sea clutter after pilot disembarked at 1505 hours

Figure 5-16: ALL ship with ARPA speed vector at 1510 hours

Figure 5-17: No.10 target echo swapped at 1508 and 1509 hours

Figure 5-18: First coursed change for target 10 at 1512 hours

Figure 5-19: Graphical solution to solve collision mystery at 1510 hours

Figure 5-20: maintain coursed for target no.12 at 1514 hours

Figure 5-21: Rocking ship in the pocket at 1515 hours, Rudder Cycling

Figure 5-22: First stage of full rudder turn at 1517 hours

Figure 5-23: Second stage of full rudder turn at 1518 hours

Figure 5-24: collision happened at third stage of full rudder turn 1519 hours